How personal loan marketplaces work, and how they get paid

What happens after you fill in a loan marketplace's form: the soft pull, who sees your data, how lenders pay the marketplace, and what to check first.

In this article 6 sections

A personal-loan marketplace is a website that collects one set of details from you, checks your credit with a soft inquiry, and shows prequalified offers from several lenders at once. Credible, LendingTree, Experian, Fiona and Acorn Finance all work this way. None of them lends money. They are paid by the lenders, which is why they're free to you, and why it's worth knowing exactly how that payment works.

This guide walks through what happens to your form, how each marketplace says it earns money, whether that changes the order you see, and how a legitimate marketplace differs from the lead-selling sites regulators have gone after.

What is a personal loan marketplace?

It's a comparison service that passes your details to lenders and shows their responses. The marketplace's terms say what it is: Credible's say "Credible is not a lender and does not make credit decisions"3, and LendingTree's say it "is not a lender or a creditor"2.

Some marketplaces are standalone brands; others are the engine behind "check your rate" tools on other sites. Fiona, for example, is powered by Engine (formerly Even Financial), which claims 1,300+ partners12 and now belongs to Gen Digital through its purchase of MoneyLion. So the same lender network can sit behind several different websites.

What happens after you submit the form?

The marketplace runs a soft credit inquiry, sends your profile to the lenders in its network, and shows the ones that prequalify you. Nothing is final until you pick an offer and apply with that lender.

  1. The form. Name, contact details, income, the amount and purpose. Most collect more: Credible's privacy policy lists birth date, Social Security number, income and employment history among the data it may collect, and LendingTree's lists Social Security number and date of birth.
  2. The soft pull. "Checking rates won't affect your credit score," says Credible; Experian says prequalifying "generates a soft inquiry." Soft inquiries don't affect scores, as the CFPB explains8.
  3. The offers. Prequalified rates, amounts and terms from the lenders that responded. These are estimates.
  4. The application. You click through to the lender, which verifies your identity and income and usually runs a hard inquiry. LendingTree warns that "some lenders don't offer prequalification and require a hard credit pull," so read each offer before you click.

How do loan marketplaces make money?

Lenders pay them, and the payment can come at several points: when your request is delivered, when you click, when you're approved, or when the loan closes. Here is how each marketplace we review describes it.

MarketplaceWhat it says it's paid forDoes payment affect order?
LendingTree"Upfront match fees paid on delivery of a consumer request", plus closed-loan, click and call fees (10-K)"May impact how and where listings appear"
CredibleCompensation from lenders described as partners"Will not impact how or where products appear"
ExperianClicking an offer link, an approved application, an opened account"May impact how, where, and in what order"
Fiona (Engine)Compensation to "Engine by MoneyLion and its partners""May influence the selection, appearance, and order"
Acorn Finance"Lead generation fees" from providersNot stated

LendingTree's 2025 annual report1 is the clearest picture of the model: "LendingTree does not charge consumers for the use of our services," and the lender pays when your request reaches it, whether or not you borrow. That's why your request is valuable, and why lenders follow up.

Does the order of offers mean anything?

Sometimes. Where a marketplace says payments may affect the order, the first offer is not necessarily the cheapest one for you. Sort by APR yourself, and compare the amount you'd actually receive after any origination fee.

Regulators have weighed in on this. In February 2024 the CFPB issued Circular 2024-019, saying comparison-shopping operators can break the ban on abusive practices if they steer "consumers to certain products or services based on remuneration to the operator." The CFPB withdrew that circular10 along with other guidance as of May 12, 2025. The underlying law against unfair, deceptive and abusive practices still applies, but the specific guidance is gone, so the disclosures above are what you have to go on.

How is a marketplace different from a lead generator?

A marketplace shows you named offers and sends you to the lender you choose. A pure lead generator collects your application and sells it, sometimes to whoever pays most, and you may never learn who bought it.

The FTC's 2022 case against ITMedia Solutions shows what can go wrong. Its sites, including personalloans.com and badcreditloans.com, promised applications would be shared with "our network of trusted lenders." The FTC alleged that 84% of the applications11 collected since 2016 went not to lenders but to marketers, debt relief and credit repair sellers and resellers, along with Social Security numbers and bank account details. ITMedia paid $1.5 million in civil penalties and accepted limits on selling consumer data.

What should you check before you submit?

Three things: who gets your data, what you're agreeing to on your phone, and whether the offers are real prequalified ones.

  • Data. Fiona shares with MoneyLion affiliates for marketing; Acorn's partners include credit brokers who may pass data to lenders. Our comparison table lists each one.
  • Phone. Credible's, Fiona's and Acorn's terms all authorize calls or texts even if you're on the Do Not Call list. Use an email you can filter, and opt out of lenders you didn't choose.
  • Offers. Prequalified means estimated. Compare APR, fee and total cost, then apply to one.

If you then want to see numbers, check what checking several sites does to your credit first.

Want to see real numbers? Credible shows prequalified rates from several lenders after one form, with a soft credit check that doesn't affect your score. We are not a lender and never see what you enter; we may be paid by partners, and rankings aren't for sale. Approval isn't guaranteed.

Compare prequalified rates

Sources

  1. LendingTree, Inc.: Form 10-K for 2025 (filed Mar 9, 2026) sec.gov
  2. LendingTree: Terms of Use (Aug 18, 2026) lendingtree.com
  3. Credible: Terms of Use (Jul 16, 2026) credible.com
  4. Credible: personal loans and partner disclosure (checked Nov 21, 2026) credible.com
  5. Experian: personal loans and advertiser disclosure (checked Nov 21, 2026) experian.com
  6. Fiona: advertiser disclosure fiona.com
  7. Acorn Finance: Terms of Use (Feb 2026) acornfinance.com
  8. CFPB: What is a credit inquiry? consumerfinance.gov
  9. CFPB: Circular 2024-01, Preferencing and steering practices by digital intermediaries (Feb 29, 2024) consumerfinance.gov
  10. Federal Register: CFPB withdrawal of guidance documents (May 12, 2025) govinfo.gov
  11. FTC: Lead generator deceptively solicited loan applications from millions of consumers (Jan 7, 2022) ftc.gov
  12. Engine by Gen: embedded marketplace engine.tech

Facts last checked November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at editor@personalloan.now.

Compare every platform side by side

More guides